How does Gompers speech contradict the idea set forth by carnegie?

Gompers' speech emphasizes the importance of organized labor and collective bargaining as a means for workers to achieve fair wages and better working conditions, which stands in stark contrast to Carnegie's belief in the "Gospel of Wealth." While Carnegie advocated for the idea that the wealthy should use their fortunes for philanthropic purposes, Gompers argued that workers should unite and assert their rights rather than rely on the goodwill of the rich. This highlights a fundamental disagreement on how economic power should be distributed and the role of labor in society.