What is 1869 5 cent coin worth?

An 1896 five cent piece is called a Shield Nickel and depending on the condition, they can be worth 9-220 dollars. It would have to be in perfect condition (Reflective surface, few blemishes, and no major flaws). If it is very worn, and has some scratches, it would be worth about 11-20 dollars.

Source: Handbook Of United States Coins 69th Edition 2012 by: R.S. Yeoman and Edited by Kenneth Bressett