Did the stranger from tuck everlasting have a good idea?

The stranger in "Tuck Everlasting" represents the idea of immortality, which he believes to be a gift that allows for eternal life and the avoidance of death. However, his perspective raises ethical questions about the consequences of living forever, such as the loss of natural life cycles and the burden of witnessing loved ones age and die. While his intentions may seem good, the implications of his idea suggest that immortality may not be as desirable as it appears. Ultimately, the story invites readers to reflect on the value of life, death, and the human experience.