How successful is surgery to scrape the joint verus joint replacement in stopping the pain from arthritis in finger?

Surgery to scrape the joint, known as debridement, can provide temporary relief from Arthritis pain in the fingers by removing damaged tissue and debris. However, its effectiveness is often limited and may not address the underlying joint damage. In contrast, joint replacement surgery typically offers more significant and lasting pain relief, as it replaces the damaged joint with a prosthetic, improving function and quality of life. Ultimately, the choice between the two procedures depends on the severity of the arthritis and the patient's overall health.