Do you believe that Andrew Johnson should have punished the rebel states?

Andrew Johnson's approach to Reconstruction and his leniency towards the rebel states is often debated. Some argue that a harsher punishment was necessary to hold the Confederacy accountable and to ensure lasting changes in social and political structures. Others believe that his leniency aimed to promote reconciliation and reunification, ultimately facilitating a smoother transition back into the Union. Ultimately, the effectiveness of his policies remains a contentious topic in American history.