Is it possible for the Justices to provide a fair review of a case when they hear about it so briefly from the lawyers arguing it before them?

Yes, it is possible for Justices to provide a fair review of a case despite the brief presentations from lawyers. They have access to extensive written briefs, legal precedents, and prior case law, which allow them to delve deeply into the issues at hand. Additionally, the oral arguments, while concise, highlight the key points and concerns that the Justices consider when making their decisions. Ultimately, their experience and expertise enable them to analyze complex legal matters efficiently.