Yes. Peyton Manning quarterbacked the 2006 Indianapolis Colts in Super Bowl XLI (beat Chicago Bears 29-17), and quarterbacked the 2015 Denver Broncos 9 years later in Super Bowl 50 (beat Carolina Panthers 24-10). Manning also lost one Super Bowl on each team (Super Bowls 44 and 48).
Other quarterbacks have played for two different teams (with Morrall and Rutledge each on two winning teams). Earl Morrall, notably, won 9 regular season games in Miami's "perfect season" in 1972, while Bob Griese returned to win Super Bowl VII (1973). Jeff Rutledge was also on the LA Rams team for Super Bowl XIV, but did not play.
QB on 2 Super Bowl teams:
Earl Morrall, Baltimore (III, V won), Miami (VII won, VIII won)
Jeff Rutledge, New York Giants (XXI won), Washington (XXVI won)
Craig Morton, Dallas (V), Denver (XII, lost to Dallas)
- first QB to start, lose a Super Bowl for two different teams
Kurt Warner, St. Louis (XXXIV won, XXXVI), Arizona (XLII)
- second QB to start, lose a Super Bowl for two different teams
The following were on the roster, but did not play 1 or 2 of the games:
Matt Cavanaugh, San Francisco (XIX), New York Giants (XXV)
Jim McMahon, Chicago (XX), Green Bay (XXXI)
Copyright © 2026 eLLeNow.com All Rights Reserved.
