Is TV shack net legal

I have seen responses to this question, elsewhere, that say that TV Shack is legal. I fail to see how a movie that was videotaped in a movie theatre can be legal in the most generous sense of the Word. Further, I read that they changed their domain name and moved their site off shore--not the actions of a legal company.

So, when you see people tell you it is legal; they are either lying, or guilty of wishful thinking.