Why are many fans divided over 'Rogue One'?

Many fans are divided over 'Rogue One' due to its tonal shifts and departure from the traditional Star Wars formula, which some found refreshing while others viewed as inconsistent. The film's darker themes and character development elicited mixed reactions, as not all viewers connected with the new characters compared to iconic ones from the original trilogy. Additionally, debates over its pacing and narrative choices further fueled the divide among the fanbase. Ultimately, 'Rogue One' represents a bold experiment within the franchise that resonates differently with various audiences.