What is a good eye liner that does smudges as little as possible but is under 20 dollars?

One of the best pencil eyeliners that doesn't smudge too much is Makeup Forever Aqua Eyes. They come in various colors and can be found at Sephora. They normally sell for $17.00 each. Depending on your skin type is as well as what type of weather you will be in the eyeliner I find can last around 7-8 hours with no touch ups. However at the end of the day the eyeliner can take a little bit of work to remove.

the urban decay 24/7 eyeliners are creamy but they dont smudge very much an they stay on for a long time