Are your American historic society coins worth something?

Your coins, unless you ordered legal tender ( which are worth face value) are worth the scrap value of the metal in the coins. Their gold proofs and commemorative coins are worthless in that they are not solid gold or silver but only plated token slugs. If the Word replica ever pops up in the advertisement that means counterfeit and worthless. One might also take note that The American Historic Society is just a name that a marketing group concocted to sound "credible" and is not actually affiliated with any nationally recognised foundation. Buyer Beware!