Do you think Preston Brooks punished was reasonable?

Preston Brooks was a congressman known for his violent attack on Senator Charles Sumner in 1856, which many viewed as an extreme response to political disagreement. While some contemporaries praised Brooks for defending Southern honor, others condemned his actions as an unacceptable breach of civility and decorum in political discourse. Ultimately, whether his punishment was reasonable depends on one's perspective on the appropriate limits of political expression and violence. In a modern context, however, such behavior would likely be deemed wholly unacceptable.