If a 19 year old is sueing a 17 year old for physical assault can the minor get off with self defense?

It is surprising that the 19 year old was able to find an attorney who would take a case against a 17 year old. When you sue someone, you sue for something, and most 17 year olds don't own enough to make it worthwhile.

So unless the 19 year old is merely threatening to sue, then the 19 year old is having to pay several thousand dollars out of pocket.

That said, the 17 year old may claim self-defense, assuming it was. A lot will depend on what the police report said. However, if the 17 year old was never arrested, charged or found guilty of assault, then there is little chance that the 19 year old will be able to win in civil court.

Without a criminal conviction of the 17 year old, it would be difficult to prove that the 17 year old had attacked at all.

But all that said, if you have actually received legal papers notifying you of the suit - rather than just his Word that he intends to sue - then consult with an attorney. Or I should say, have your parents do so, as you are a minor.

Remember, when you speak to an attorney, do not lie to him. They can't help you if you do.