Why does carnegie take a hard line on charity?

Andrew Carnegie took a hard line on charity because he believed in the principle of the "Gospel of Wealth," which argued that the affluent have a moral obligation to distribute their wealth in ways that benefit society. He contended that indiscriminate giving could foster dependency rather than promote self-improvement. Instead, he advocated for strategic philanthropy that empowered individuals and communities, emphasizing education and infrastructure over direct financial aid. This approach aimed to encourage personal responsibility and create lasting societal change.